On Verifying the Accuracy of Information: Philosophical Perspectives

Fallis, Don (2004) On Verifying the Accuracy of Information: Philosophical Perspectives. Library Trends 52(3).

Full text available as:
PDF - Requires Adobe Acrobat Reader or other PDF viewer.

Abstract

How can one verify the accuracy of recorded information (e.g., information found in books, newspapers, and on Web sites)? In this paper, I argue that work in the epistemology of testimony (especially that of philosophers David Hume and Alvin Goldman) can help with this important practical problem in library and information science. This work suggests that there are four important areas to consider when verifying the accuracy of information: (i) authority, (ii) independent corroboration, (iii) plausibility and support, and (iv) presentation. I show how philosophical research in these areas can improve how information professionals go about teaching people how to evaluate information. Finally, I discuss several further techniques that information professionals can and should use to make it easier for people to verify the accuracy of information.

EPrint Type:	Journal Article (On-line/Unpaginated)
Keywords:	accuracy, information, testimony, epistemology, verifiability
Subjects:	Philosophy Internet Social Epistemology
ID Code:	1580
Deposited On:	20 October 2006
Eprint Statistics:	View statistics for this eprint
Tell A Colleague:	Tell a colleague about it.

Alcoff, L. M. (1999). On judging epistemic credibility: Is social identity relevant? Philosophic Exchange, 29, 73-89.

Alexander, J. E., & Tate, M. A. (1999). Web wisdom. Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Ambre, J., Guard, R., Perveiler, F. M., Renner, J., & Rippen, H. (1997). Criteria for assessing the quality of health information on the Internet. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://hitiweb.mitretek.org/docs/criteria.html.

Atkinson, R. (1996). Library functions, scholarly communication, and the foundation of the digital library: Laying claim to the control zone. Library Quarterly, 66(3), 239-265.

Baird, D. G., Gertner, R. H., & Picker, R. C. (1994). Game theory and the law. Cambridge: Harvard.

Berland, G. K., Elliott, M. N., Morales, L. S., Algazy, J. I., Kravitz, R. L., Broder, M. S., Kanouse, D. E., Muñoz, J. A., Puyol, J.-A., Lara, M., Watkins, K. E., Yang, H., & McGlynn, E. A. (2001). Health information on the internet: accessibility, quality, and readability in English and Spanish. JAMA, 285(20), 2612-2621.

Bruce, B. (2000). Credibility of the web: Why we need dialectical reading. Journal of Philosophy of Education, 34(1), 97-109.

Burbules, N. C. (2001). Paradoxes of the web: The ethical dimensions of credibility. Library Trends, 49(3), 441-453.

Bureau of Engraving and Printing. (2002). Anti-counterfeiting: Security features. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.bep.treas.gov/section.cfm/7/35

Cerf, V. G. (2002). Truth and the internet. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://info.isoc.org/internet/conduct/truth.shtml.

Cleveland State University. (2002). Cleveland digital library. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://web.ulib.csuohio.edu/SpecColl/cdl/.

Coady, C. A. J. (1992). Testimony. New York: Oxford.

Connell, T. H., & Tipple, J. E. (1999). Testing the accuracy of information on the World Wide Web using the AltaVista search engine. Reference & User Services Quarterly, 38(4), 360-368.

Cooke, A. (1999). Neal-Schuman authoritative guide to evaluating information on the Internet. New York: Neal-Schuman.

Digital Library of Information Science and Technology. (2002). Digital library of information science and technology. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://dlist.sir.arizona.edu.

Doyle, T. (2001). A utilitarian case for intellectual freedom in libraries. Library Quarterly, 71(1), 44-71.

Eysenbach, G., & Köhler, C. (2002). How do consumers search for and appraise health information on the World Wide Web? Qualitative study using focus groups, usability tests, and in-depth interviews. British Medical Journal, 324, 573-577.

Fallis, D. (1999). Inaccurate consumer health information on the internet: Criteria for evaluating potential solutions. Proceedings of the Annual Symposium of the American Medical Informatics Association. Retrieved February 1, 2003, from http://www.amia.org/pubs/symposia/D005366.PDF.

Fallis, D. (2000). Veritistic social epistemology and information science. Social Epistemology, 14(4), 305-316.

Fallis, D., & Frické, M. (2002). Indicators of accuracy of consumer health information on the Internet: A study of indicators relating to information for managing fever in children in the home. Journal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 9(1), 73-79.

Floridi, L. (2002a). On defining library and information science as applied philosophy of information. Social Epistemology, 16(1), 37-49.

Floridi, L. (2002b). What is the philosophy of information? Metaphilosophy, 33(1/2), 123-145.

Floridi, L. (2002c). On the intrinsic value of information objects and the infosphere. Ethics and Information Technology, 4, 287-304.

Fogg, B. J., Marshall, J., Laraki, O., Osipovich, A., Varma, C., Fang, N., Paul, J., Rangnekar, A., Shon, J., Swani, P., & Treinen, M. (2001). What makes web sites credible? A report on a large quantitative study. Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, 61-68.

Fowler, B., Franklin, C., & Hyde, R. (2001). Internet securities fraud: Old trick, new medium. Duke Law and Technology Review, (6). Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.law.duke.edu/journals/dltr/ARTICLES/2001dltr0006.html

Frické, M. (1997). Information using likeness measures. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 48(10), 882-892.

Froomkin, A. M. (1996). The essential role of trusted third parties in electronic commerce. Oregon Law Review, 75, 49-115.

Giedymin, J. (1963). Reliability of informants. British Journal for the Philosophy of Science, 13(52), 287-302.

Goldman, A. I. (1987). Foundations of social epistemics. Synthese, 73(1), 109-144.

Goldman, A. I. (1999). Knowledge in a social world. New York: Oxford.

Goldman, A. I. (2001). Experts: Which ones should you trust? Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 63(1), 85-110.

Griffiths, K. M., & Christensen, H. (2000). Quality of web based information on treatment of depression: Cross-sectional survey. British Medical Journal, 321, 1511-1515.

Hardwig, J. (1985). Epistemic dependence. Journal of Philosophy, 82(7), 335-349.

Hardwig, J. (1994). Toward an ethics of expertise. D. E. Wueste (ed.), Professional ethics and social responsibility (pp. 83-101). Lanham, Maryland: Rowman and Littlefield.

Health on the Net Foundation. (2002). HON code of conduct for medical and health web sites. Retrieved February 1, 2003, from http://www.hon.ch/HONcode/Conduct.html.

Health on the Net Foundation. (2002). Policing the HONcode. Retrieved February 1, 2003, from http://www.hon.ch/HONcode/policy.html.

Hernon, P. (1995). Disinformation and misinformation through the internet: Findings of an exploratory study. Government Information Quarterly, 12(2), 133-139.

Herold, K. R. (2001). Librarianship and the philosophy of information. Library Philosophy and Practice, 3(2). Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.uidaho.edu/~mbolin/lppv3n2.htm

Hume, D. (1977 [1748]). An enquiry concerning human understanding. Indianapolis: Hackett.

Impicciatore, P., Pandolfini, C., Casella, N., & Bonati, M. (1997). Reliability of health information for the public on the World Wide Web: Systematic survey of advice on managing fever in children at home. British Medical Journal, 314, 1875-1879.

Internet Scout Project. (2003a). Internet Scout Project. Retrieved February 1, 2003, from http://scout.cs.wisc.edu.

Internet Scout Project. (2003b). Internet Scout Project report selection criteria. Retrieved February 1, 2003, from http://scout.cs.wisc.edu/about/criteria.html.

Kaufmann, W. (1977). The future of the humanities. New York: Reader's Digest Press.

Ketelaar, E. (1997). Can we trust information? International Information And Library Review , 29, 333-338.

Kiley, R. (2002). Some evidence exists that the Internet does harm health. British Medical Journal, 324, 238.

Kunst, H., Groot, D., Latthe, P. M., Latthe, M., & Khan, K. S. (2002). Accuracy of information on apparently credible websites: Survey of five common health topics. British Medical Journal, 321, 581-582.

Landsburg, S. E. (1999, September 15). Too true to be good: The real reason you can’t believe everything you read. Slate. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://slate.msn.com/?id=34856

Lee, K. P., Schotland, M., Bacchetti, P., & Bero, L. A. (2002). Association of journal quality indicators with methodological quality of clinical research articles. JAMA, 287(21), 2805-2808.

Locke, J. (1975 [1690]). An essay concerning human understanding. Oxford: Oxford.

Lipton, P. (1998). The epistemology of testimony. Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science, 29(1), 1-31.

McDowell, A. (2002). Trust and information: The role of trust in the social epistemology of information science. Social Epistemology, 16(1), 51-63.

Meola, M. (2000). Review of Knowledge in a social world by Alvin I. Goldman. College and Research Libraries, 61(2), 173-174.

Mill, J. S. (1978 [1859]). On liberty. Indianapolis: Hackett.

Monmonier, M. (1991). How to lie with maps. Chicago: University of Chicago.

National Library of Medicine. (2002). Fever and children. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/001980.htm.

Perry, J. A. (1985). The Dillion hypothesis of titular colonicity: An empirical test from the ecological sciences. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 36(4), 251-258.

Perry, J. A. (1986). Titular colonicity: Further developments. Journal of the American Society for Information Science, 37(3), 177-178.

Piper, P. S. (2000). Better read that again: Web hoaxes and misinformation. Searcher, 8(8). Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.infotoday.com/searcher/sep00/piper.htm

Plato. (2002 [380 BC]). Charmides. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/cgi-bin/ptext?lookup=Plat.+Charm.+153a.

Price, S. L., & Hersh, W. R. (1999). Filtering web pages for quality indicators: An empirical approach to finding high quality consumer health information on the World Wide Web. Proceedings of the Annual Symposium of the American Medical Informatics Association, 911-915.

Rieh, S. Y. (2002). Judgment of information quality and cognitive authority in the Web. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 53(2), 145-161.

Salmon, M. H. (1995). Introduction to logic and critical thinking (3rd ed.). Fort Worth: Harcourt Brace & Company.

SBC Pacific Bell. (2002). Blue Web’n. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.kn.pacbell.com/wired/bluewebn/.

Shapin, S. (1994). A social history of truth. Chicago: University of Chicago.

Shera, J. (1970). Sociological foundations of librarianship. New York: Asia Publishing House.

Silberg, W. M., Lundberg, G. D., & Musacchio, R. A. (1997). Assessing, controlling, and assuring the quality of medical information on the internet. JAMA, 277(15), 1244-1245.

Smith, A. (2002). Evaluation of information sources. The World-Wide Web Virtual Library. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.vuw.ac.nz/~agsmith/evaln/evaln.htm.

Smith, C. (2002). Social epistemology, contextualism and the division of labour. Social Epistemology, 16(1), 65-81.

Spence, M. (1974). Market signaling. Cambridge: Harvard.

Thagard, P. (2001). Internet epistemology: Contributions of new information technologies to scientific research. K. Crowley, C. D. Schunn, & T. Okada (eds.), Designing for science: Implications from professional, instructional, and everyday science (pp. 465-485). Mawah, New Jersey: Erlbaum.

Wachbroit, R. (2000). Reliance and reliability: The problem of information on the Internet. Report from the Institute for Philosophy & Public Policy, 20(4), 9-15. Retrieved August 1, 2002, from http://www.puaf.umd.edu/IPPP/reports/vol20fall00/Fall2000.pdf.

Wathen, C. N., & Burkell, J. (2002). Believe it or not: Factors influencing credibility on the Web. Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology, 53(2), 134-144.

Wengert, R. (2001). Some ethical aspects of being an information professional. Library Trends, 49(3), 486-509.

Wilde, O. (2003 [1895]). The importance of being earnest. Retrieved February 1, 2003, from http://www.classicbookshelf.com/library/oscar_wilde/the_importance_of_being_earnest/.

Wilkinson, G. L., Bennett, L. T., & Oliver, K. M. (1997). Evaluation criteria and indicators of quality for Internet resources. Educational Technology, 37(3), 52-59.

Wilson, P. (1983). Second-hand knowledge: An inquiry into cognitive authority. Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood.

Worsfold, E. (1998). Subject gateways: Fulfilling the DESIRE for knowledge. Computer Networks and ISDN Systems, 30(16-18), 1479-1489.